For the longest time the responsible narrative around “AI” usage was: You can use AI as support but you really have to check all responses for correctness.
This was a very obvious attempt to address one of the most pressing issues with “AI”: The way it lowers the quality by introducing random errors. Surely nobody would have an issue with people using “AI” if they checked all the outputs, right?
Well of course people do have issues: Disenfranchisement of Labor, ecological impact of energy and water use as well as the creation of e-waste, the massive illegal accumulation of everyone’s work products and the negative impact on human cognition and flourishing should be more than enough to stop basically everyone from using those systems but ethics are not in fashion.
But if we stayed in the capitalist logic of the end/output/productivity justifying the means this does – at first glance – look sorta reasonable? But what always irked me was how this did not correspond to my experience at all: Reading, editing, validating someone else’s work takes a lot of time, especially when you need to be focused enough to catch those kinds of weird errors that LLMs introduce. I never understood where the time savings were supposed to come from. I did have a suspicion though.
Ketan Joshi has created an infographic outlining what I thought was going on:

But I recently see a shift in how “AI” proponents are talking about their usage. Because where the old (probably bogus) approach at least claimed to care about quality and keeping it somewhat up, we now don’t even get that promise anymore.
I keep seeing in my environment and hearing from other people more and more stories of “We don’t need to check things, if something’s broken, the AI will just fix it” or “we just use an AI to check the results”. Two stochastic wrongs maybe creating a right seemingly being the hopes and dreams and thoughts and prayers.
This is a massive shifting of the goalposts in “AI” defense. Which in general is a weird thing to do, because why defend something that unethical but it did try to claim not to make the world worse through creating shittier artifacts. But now we’re just full speed ahead into slop-world. What if Fast Fashion but for everything?
I think this shows us a handful of things. First it illustrates how “AI” (including those set up in “responsible” ways) cannot provide both: Productivity gains as well as consistent quality. It is a confession of sorts.
Second it does also illustrate how far into capitalist accelerationalism we’re leaning in general: If something is just faster, quickly satisfying some of our impulse that can be framed as a positive without being laughed of the stage or slapped in the face.
Third it shows that the “AI” crowd will never commit to anything and that all claims and promises from that camp are moot. They are running from society always claiming to provide something and never providing it. Because everything changes so much … innovation … old paradigms … bla bla bla.
I think it’s important to cast a light on this shift, on how all these systems were funded, developed and deployed under the promise of ensuring quality and responsibility and now that it has become obvious that that would never work, we’re slowly but surely narratively prepared to accept more and more slop in our lives.
But we must not.
Many of the criticisms against “AI” (exploitation, lack of regard for externalities, etc.) can also be made against most capitalist forms of production. “AI” isn’t special in that regard. But that weird asterisk that accompanies every “AI” system pushing all responsibility on the users who get put under more and more pressure to provide efficiency gains that “AI” cannot deliver must be put at the center of criticism within mainstream discourse – a discourse that sadly often also doesn’t care about ethics or environmental impact or people’s dignity.
Accepting slop means accepting objectively worse digital objects – produced at incredible costs to the environment, our societies, our cognitive and mental health. And that is where I think one of the first lines needs to be drawn.
California just sued OpenAI over them using stochastic systems to attack other organizations’ websites and platforms (it is very important to not adapt the framing of “their AI attacking” because that’s 100% not what is happening). This is another step of undermining the framing of “AI” being special, needing special rules and not having to obey to established norms and laws. Norms like for example you as a service provider having to reliably provide the service you promised.
If you apply that kind of common sense understanding of services to “AI” based services, none of them will survive. So let’s get to it.
